Thursday, 29 November 2007

LEAVE GRANTED WITH COSTS!!!

Here is the press release from the SCC:

http://scc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/news_release/2007/07-11-29.3a/07-11-29.3a.html

LEAVE GRANTED!!!

We are going to the Supreme Court of Canada!
Leave was granted today for Nanc's case to proceed. We have been expecting it for the last few weeks, hence nothing to report. It has been a tense time but now another hurdle has been passed. Jack (Nanc's lawyer) is excited about the opportunity to craft new law setting down much needed guidelines for the process of forming agreements in family law. That is really the core of Nanc's case. It is unconscionable that a stronger spouse can literally hold a gun to the other spouse's head to force him or her to sign an agreement, and then have that agreement be unassailable by legal means. That was the gist of the Appeals Court's decision, and it can not be allowed to stand!
More later, we are too excited.........

Tuesday, 6 November 2007

TOCK!

canada, canadian search engine, free email, canada news
Wednesday » December 19 » 2007

Top court petitioned on divorce equality
Wife loses out because of 'access to legal advice'

Joey Thompson
The Province

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

An Abbotsford mom who claims she came up $600,000 short in a mediated separation deal with her ex-husband is hoping Canada's top court will grant her plea for pay equity.

Fifty-two-year-old Nancy Rick says she proposed the settlement pay-out to Ben Brandsema while an emotional wreck triggered by a strict, abusive upbringing and aggravated by 28 stormy years with the dairy farmer.

The mother of four, who tried to end her life while in her teens, said she was too vulnerable and confused, a result of post-traumatic-stress disorder, to see she wasn't getting her fair share. Nor was she able to detect that Brandsema hadn't disclosed the true value of the couple's many holdings, including several large properties, cattle, a milk quota, equipment, vehicles and RRSPs.

She said she was too depressed to even read, much less do the math on the 2001 split-up agreement that gave her approximately $1 million.

Indeed, a specialist in post-trauma psychiatry testified that Rick's PTSD symptoms were "among the most extreme" he had ever seen.

A trial judge in B.C. Supreme Court agreed the homemaker, who laboured on the farm alongside her husband, was troubled and that Brandsema, knowing she was mentally unstable when they began negotiating, took advantage of her.

Justice Harry Slade said Rick received only 30 per cent of the family assets instead of the 50/50 split the couple had initially planned on -- partly because Brandsema had provided misleading information about their $3-million estate after they split in 2000.

He said Brandsema owed her an additional $649,680.

But B.C.'s top court said too bad, so sad if Rick missed the boat. After all, the all-male panel noted, she had consulted lawyers, accountants and two mediators. In a 2003 decision, the Supreme Court of Canada implied that access to professional legal advice can compensate for some vulnerabilities or imbalances.

"Should the husband have been obliged to tell the wife that her proposal was not enough and that she should demand more?" top court Justice Edward Chiasson asked.

"This is not a case of mental incapacity, undue influence or duress. [They] were participating in mediation, part of that process involved the recommendation that the parties obtain legal advice. The wife had done so and did so again.

"[She] was troubled but it is clear that she knew what she was doing."

Chiasson said the lower court allowed equality to trump fairness.

But family law lawyer Jack Hittrich says the appeal court's ruling sends a disturbing, chilling message to Canadians: Even when a separating spouse has mental-health issues, even when there was misrepresentation as to assets, even when they both intended that their assets be equalized, as long as they had access to legal advice, the agreement will be binding.

"This case raises significant issues of national importance about the duties of negotiating parties in family law agreements," he states in a written petition to the nation's top court. "Without proper judicial guidance from our highest court, thousands of future couples will either be deprived of just settlements or will have to face costly and uncertain litigation."

- - -

Phone: 604-605-2119

Fax: 604-605-2099

jthompson@png.canwest.com
© The Vancouver Province 2007


Close

Copyright © 2007 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.

Monday, 29 October 2007

Still between

Well, the time between tick and tock has become longer than we expected. Tock is now 2 weeks late, but it is still coming!
In the mean time, my big court battle has been resolved to my satisfaction. We reached an agreement in principle with the other parties and are now just working out the logistics of doing that which has never been done. Tick and tock again, but mine will resolve on December 4,5,or 6 or the agreement goes down the drain. I don't think either side wants that to happen. Watch the national news and CPAC during this period, it will be historic.
There is that old Chinese curse about living in interesting times.....

Thursday, 11 October 2007

THE TIME BETWEEN TICK AND TOCK

We have learned that much of life exists between the tick and tock of events. We are in such a place now. One great event has occurred, and we must wait for the inevitable tock that follows. "Tock" occurs (god willing and the creek don't rise)on next Tuesday, October 16th. I will be posting about it, but right now I don't want to throw any monkey wrenches into the clockworks (to extend the metaphor perhaps a bit too far). In the mean time, I want to share some quotes on fear that struck Nanc and I as appropriate to this time:

Eleanor Roosevelt:
You gain strength, courage, and confidence by every experience in which you really stop to look fear in the face. You must do the thing which you think you cannot do.

Marcus Aurelius:
If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.

David Oliver-Godric:
Fear is one of the essences of what it is to be alive. Courage is to have fear but act anyway, cowardice is to have fear and fail to act. Life is about action, failing to act is the same as being dead, although even the dead act as fertilizer so perhaps it is worse.

See you Tuesday!

Thursday, 4 October 2007

NUTSHELL - PART 2

The abuser appealed and won his appeal before 3 male judges who had little family law background. They were corporate contract lawyers. Their mantra was "if you sign it you are done, regardless". In their finding, they say some very bizare things. According to them, Nanc knew perfectly well what she was doing when she signed the documents (that she couldn't even read), She had access to a lawyer and accountants, and it isn't the abuser's fault that they were incompetent and relying on the abuser's fraudulent financial info. The appeals court dismissed the trial judge's findings of fact. Nanc has appealed to the SCC to overturn the BC Appeals Court Ruling in the interest of justice, equity, and clarity of law. We are currently awaiting leave to appeal to the SCC.

!!!WOMEN TAKE NOTE: this finding is a LEGAL precedent that means that an abusive spouse has no obligation under the law to provide accurate financial info. Banks and accountants are encouraged to deny the woman access to her own accounts and financial info.
Your mental/emotional state at the break up of the marriage is of no interest to the court, you are assumed to be equally as competent as your spouse/abuser. Abusers are not accountable for tormenting their spouses into submission.
Merely having access to professionals is sufficient to assume proper and competent legal and financial advice.

This decision should scare the hell out of every woman in Canada, and make every legal professional hang their head in shame.

IN A NUTSHELL

Several people now have asked for a simple version of what this is all about. I sat down to write a "simple" version and found that harder to do than I thought. Like life in general, it's just not a simple thing. Did my best, though.
The nutshell version is this: Nanc was in an extremely abusive relationship for 27 years. She lived in near isolation on a dairy farm, and her church and community turns a blind eye to even obvious abuse. Her 2 youngest girls removed her from the farm in 2001 in a basically catatonic state. Nanc got a bit better, still suffering what her doctor termed “one of the most severe cases of PTSD” he had ever seen and he is a specialist in PTSD, and she commenced divorce proceedings. Her abuser provided all the financial info relied upon in negotiations, and we have subsequently proved he hid large amounts of money, the full extent will never be known. Now Nanc is absolutely brilliant in matters of the heart and family, but she never finished grade 10, she was never involved in the finances of the business. Nanc was in such a highly emotional state that she found that she was unable to see what was written on documents relating to the divorce. We now understand this to be a symptom of her PTSD. Nanc signed the agreement, relying on advice from an incompetent lawyer that she could revisit the agreement’s terms within a 2 year period. I came into her life about this time and introduced her to a competent lawyer, Jack Hittrich. Nanc went to court to have the agreement overturned. She testified to the circumstances in court and the trial judge found her credible and the agreement unconscionable.

Saturday, 29 September 2007

Climbing Out Broken Windows: Domestic Violence and Abuse: Signs and Symptoms of Abusive Relationships

This is an excellent resource for warning signs and a description of what a severely abusive relationship looks like. Nanc's experiences, as related to myself, her lawyer, and led as evidence in court, matches this description to a "t". It is a blog by a New York survivor, so resources listed are mostly American.


Climbing Out Broken Windows: Domestic Violence and Abuse: Signs and Symptoms of Abusive Relationships

Thursday, 27 September 2007

FAMILY RELATIONS ACT - NEEDED CHANGES

Nanc's lawyer, Jack Hittrich, has been practising family law for many years and has become concerned by certain deficiencies unique to family law. He is part of a working group of lawyers that have come to grips with ways to address these issues. Many of these issues were central to Nanc's experience with the justice system. This post is a preliminary report:


C.B.A. FAMILY LAW SUBSECTION SUBMISSIONS ON DISCLOSURE PRINCIPLES IN REFORMING FAMILY LAW RULES

Mr. Justice Fraser in Cunha v. Cunha [1994] B.C..No. 2573, brilliant description of “non disclosure” as “the cancer of matrimonial property litigation” is applicable to all areas of family law. Accessing reliable financial information at an early stage and with a minimum of expense and complexity should the primary objective and underlying rationale in the current review of our disclosure rules.

The current Supreme Court and Provincial Court Rules are a good start but simply do not go far enough. Very real barriers continue to exist to obtaining accurate and reliable financial information upon which informed decisions can be made. A complex, expensive, and often unpredictable court process is frequently necessary to determine income and asset information in cases of self employed individuals.

It is unfortunate that our adversarial legal system places the onus on usually the weaker spouse, who lacks the knowledge and often the financial means, to prove on a balance of probabilities that her spouse (yes, this is usually gender specific) has income at a certain level or has this or that asset and what its value is. Why force the weaker party to spend thousands and thousands of dollars on lawyers, forensic accountants and business valuators to prove income levels and business values when the party in control of the key financial information can often sit back and wait to see if his (yes, it is usually “his”) spouse will tire and hopefully give up and take a settlement which is less than fair?

The key here is to shift the burden and expense of disclosure to the spouse who controls the financial information. The traditional burden of proof on a balance of probabilities on the claiming party is deeply flawed in the area of disclosure in family law.


Why should there be a requirement to commence litigation before the disclosure rules of our courts apply? Why should the party seeking the disclosure through the court process be required to seek costs, usually at a small fraction of their real costs? Why should the non disclosing party have the opportunity to delay and then produce at the last minute knowing very well how lax courts tend to be about awarding costs?

There are a number of useful ideas in this area and they include the following:

1. There should be an automatic right to seek full financial disclosure by means of appropriate demands, without the need to start any legal action. Supreme Court Rule 60D could be amended to include pre writ disclosure demands.

2. If the demand is on a self employed individual, in addition to the usual disclosure requirements, there should be a clearly specified requirement to produce banking records, both personal and business, over a period of 2 to 3 years.

3. The forms for financial demands should clearly spell out that failure to produce by a stipulated date will automatically result in a fixed financial penalty unless the non disclosing party brings on a successful application in court to show cause why the penalty should not apply.

4. If the commencement of legal action is required for failure to comply with disclosure, special costs should normally be awarded unless the offending party can show compelling reasons to the contrary.

5. The scope of Interrogatories should be broadened to include demand for specified documents.

6. There should be the option in family cases to specify on a Demand for Lists of Documents the subject area in issue.

7. Photocopying costs and costs of accessing third party documents should be controlled as much as possible with an automatic payment out of family assets unless cause can be shown otherwise.

8. Judicial Case Conference and Family Case Conference Judges and Masters should have broad and specific powers to order extensive financial disclosure with meaningful penalty provisions in case of non compliance.



9. At any stage of the proceeding, either party should be able to bring on an application to fund the full costs of an appropriate investigation and report into financial matters with legal fees, accounting fees, and disbursements paid by the other party or from family assets.

10. Non disclosure, partial disclosure, and financial ability to bear costs, should be specified criteria in the awarding of costs to fund investigations and reports into financial matters.

11. Rule 60D should be clearly linked to Rules 32 and 32A with expanded powers for court appointed masters, registrars, special referees and experts to investigate and report on financial matters. FRA s. 15 investigations and reports into custody and access matters are well known and routinely ordered while Rules 32 and 32A are little known and rarely used to investigating and report on financial matters.

12. If there is a judicial finding of material non-disclosure, there should be specific legislative authority for judges to reverse the onus of proof on evidence and to draw appropriate adverse inferences against the non disclosing party, essentially incorporating the rationale of Cunha v. Cunha. This goes beyond the scope of procedural law and will require amendments to the FRA and possibly the Divorce Act.

The foregoing ideas are expressed in very general terms. They arise from the collective financial and emotional pain of numerous disadvantaged spouses who have a bitter taste in their mouth about the substantial procedural hurdles that they faced in the current family justice system. It is time to make the family justice system more user friendly and more just.

ALL OF WHICH IS RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED
September , 2007

Jack Hittrich, Chair of the Law Reform Committee of the Westminster Sub Section
David Hart
Janet L. Clark

David Halkett
with input from David Dundee
and J.P. Boyd

Wednesday, 26 September 2007

What IS the role of the church in family violence events?

Jeannie Babb Taylor: An open letter to Christian pastors

09/23/07
Jeannie Babb Taylor
Respond to this story
Email this story to a friend

Jeannie Babb Taylor, On the Other Hand

Pastors, have you ever preached a sermon against domestic violence? Odds are, you haven’t. I’ve listened to approximately 4,000 sermons and have yet to hear a pastor condemn domestic violence from the pulpit.

Southern preachers prefer to pontificate on matters like abortion and homosexuality. Sometimes they rail against feminism. On occasion they preach against pornography, using the occasion to slam churchwomen over immodest attire. In every denomination, pastors preach often enough on tithing, and never fail to pass the plate. Yet they fail at addressing an issue faced by approximately one fourth of their congregation.

Recently a wildly popular pastor shoved the problem of Christian violence into the spotlight when he choked, kicked and stomped his wife in the parking lot of an Atlanta hotel. In the South, beating your wife may or may not be a crime. Records show that the most common law enforcement response to domestic violence is “separating the parties.” Victims rarely press charges because they fear reprisal. Law enforcement rarely presses their own charges (though they could and should), essentially treating wife-beating as a “victimless crime.”

Bishop Thomas W. Weeks, III crossed the line that even Georgia will not tolerate: He was wearing shoes when he kicked his wife. That’s a felony. Besides that, he committed the acts publicly and on video surveillance tape. He also threatened to kill her, which is another Georgia felony.

The abused wife, Prophetess Juanita Bynum, is an internationally acclaimed televangelist and best-selling author who empowers Christian women with her preaching. Church members say that couple of weeks before the attack, Weeks announced that Bynum would no longer be preaching at the church they founded.

Bynum is pressing charges against Weeks and seeking to end the marriage. Attorneys for Weeks say he will contest the divorce on the grounds that she was cruel. The strangest part of this story is not that the man who kicked and stomped his wife is contesting the divorce or fighting the charges; that happens all the time. What is so bizarre is where this man was just a few days after the beating: He was behind his pulpit telling his congregation that the devil made him do it.

Finally, a preacher is talking about domestic violence! If only his congregation had responded with a resounding movement down the aisle – and right out the church door. No one should sit under the teaching of a wife-beater. The elders should have stripped this man of his title and never let him behind the pulpit again.

T. D. Jakes, the famous televangelist who helped bring Bynum to power, condemned violence against women in a written statement two weeks after the attack. He pointed out that every day, four American men murder their wives or girlfriends, resulting in 1,400 deaths per year. That’s an FBI statistic. He also mentioned that over half a million cases of intimate assault are reported each year. Most cases go unreported. According to the most conservative estimates, between 2,000,000 and 4,000,000 women are battered each year. In 1990, the U.S. had 3,800 shelters for animals, and only 1,500 shelters for battered women.

Other Christian leaders even try to blame the victims. Christian author Gillis Triplett claims that there are thirteen traits common to abused wives, including “THEY LOVE THE DRAMA!” (Emphasis his.) Evangelical leaders John MacArthur and James Dobson have both gone on record stating that women must be careful not to “provoke” abuse. In the 1996 printing of “Love Must Be Tough,” Dobson told a story about a woman who was physically beaten by her husband. Dobson concluded that the woman “baited” her husband to hit her so that she could show off her black eye, which he calls her “prize.”

Following the advice and example of such leaders, thousands of pastors regularly dismiss domestic violence and send women back into dangerous situations. With “saving the marriage” as the highest aim, these pastors seek to prevent divorce at all costs. Women receive the subtle message that their pain – or even their lives -- are not as important as keeping the marriage intact.

One woman told a victims’ support group how she took her children and fled the state in fear of her life. Her church responded by sending her a letter of ex-communication.

In the introduction to her new book “Woman Submit! Christians & Domestic Violence,” Jocylen Andersen states that “The practice of hiding, ignoring, and even perpetuating the emotional and physical abuse of women is ... rampant within evangelical Christian fellowships and as slow as our legal systems have been in dealing with violence against women by their husbands, the church has been even slower.” The Christian wife abuse cover-up is every bit as evil as the Catholic sex abuse cover-up.

Christian leaders set the stage for domestic violence by perpetuating pop-culture stereotypes of femininity and masculinity. T. D. Jakes claims in his book “Woman, Thou Art Loosed” that all women were created to fulfill the vision of some man. Jakes bases his gender theology solely on the physical characteristics of male and female genitalia, insisting that all women are “receivers” and all men are “givers.” This false dichotomy breaks down quickly when one considers that female sexuality includes giving birth and giving milk. More importantly, Jakes deviates from Scripture in claiming that women and men must operate like their genitalia in every facet of life.

John MacArthur also does his part to set the stage for female subjugation. He calls the women’s movement “Satanic.” In a sermon called “God’s Design for a Successful Marriage: The Role of the Wife” MacArthur blames working women for everything from smog to prison overcrowding. As an antidote, he offers this quote from Charles Haddon Spurgeon on the disposition of a godly wife toward her husband: “He is her little world, her paradise, her choice treasure. She is glad to sink her individuality in him.”

Finally, consider Paige Patterson, president of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Patterson recently dismissed Hebrew professor Sheri Klouda, simply because she was female. He claims the Bible does not allow women to instruct men. Patterson then launched a new major at the seminary: Homemaking. Only women are allowed to take these courses, which focus on childcare, cooking and sewing -- as well as a woman’s role in marriage. The courses are taught by Patterson’s wife, who is the only surviving female in the school’s 42-person theology faculty.

Considering Patterson’s view of women, we should not be surprised at his response to domestic violence. Participating in a panel on “How Submission Works in Practice,” Patterson tells abused wives to do three things: Pray for their husbands, submit to them, and “elevate” them. He admits that this advice sometimes leads to beatings, but also claims that the men eventually get saved. Apparently, it’s only the men that matter.

Pastors who truly want to help people and save marriages should stop attacking feminism. Instead, teach couples never to hit, choke, kick, threaten or verbally batter their spouse. Preach against domestic violence from your pulpit. Help abuse victims to escape their batterers – permanently. Encourage them to press charges so that justice can be served.

Pastors, if you want to defend marriage, set an example of a loving relationship. Instruct couples to live in a way that makes their spouse want to stay with them. It really does not take a six-tape series to teach the number one tool of a successful marriage: the golden rule.

Jeannie Babb Taylor is a local business leader and author. She also teaches Sunday school, educates her children at home, and engages in Georgia politics. Jeannie may be contacted at jeannie@babb.com, or you can leave a public comment on her blog OntheOtherHandColumn.blogspot.com.